Review: Murdered by my Father (BBC 3)

MBMF

Warning: this post contains spoilers (although the title gives it away tbh)

The recently aired BBC 3 drama Murdered by my Father is an incredibly powerful depiction of the circumstances in which ‘honour’-based violence takes place. Screenwriter Vinay Patel developed the story following detailed consultation with specialist support charity IKWRO (the Iranian and Kurdish Women’s Rights Organisation), among others. We learn that London teenager Salma (Kiran Sonia Sawar) is betrothed from an early age to the son of her father’s business associate Haroon (Salman Akhtar), and despite trying hard to honour her father’s wishes, her love for Imi (Mawaan Rizwan) makes it impossible for her to reconcile the idea of getting married to anyone else. Though she and her widower father Shahzad (played by Adeel Akhtar) share a warm relationship to begin with, his control on Salma’s life tightens considerably as the pressure on him increases to force her into line and ‘protect his reputation’. Haroon points out her Western taste in music, and suggests that she has been ‘looking at boys’.  Shahzad himself notices her striking lingerie in the wash basket at home, and the situation takes a turn for the worst when he receives a letter from her school expressing concern at her poor attendance – she had been truanting in order to spend what time she could with Imi. Alerted to her behaviour, he sets a date for the wedding to Haroon, despite his earlier promise to Salma that she would be allowed to finish her studies. We see Salma’s despair as she is torn between her father’s emotional blackmail and the desire to live her own life. After running away to safety, Salma is tricked into coming back to the house, where her father strangles and suffocates her to death.

Patel has done a fantastic job of conveying the social backdrop to this very specific type of violence. We know that Salma previously tried to break up with Imi, but she was unable to resist getting back together with him. When his sister catches him looking at her at a wedding, she warns him to leave her alone, saying, “I’d prefer it if I didn’t have to tell mum why her darling puthar got his head kicked in at a wedding.” She recognises the threat to both of them. In fact Salma’s every movement is policed by everyone from the nosy neighbours to her own little brother, who isn’t even a teenager himself. Whenever she is with Imi, she’s constantly frightened and always aware of who might be watching. Patel captures the horror of a well-meaning outside force putting a victim at grave risk of harm with the letter from the school alerting her father to her absence. Many victims are indeed betrothed to each other from a young age in order to strengthen family ties, which in this instance are broken when Haroon tells Salma’s father that he’d rather keep the business in his own family than associate with someone who has ‘shamed’ them in the way they say he has for failing to make Salma comply. The impact of stigma from the community on ‘honour’ abusers is depicted in a particularly intense manner in the scene where Salma’s father is beaten by Haroon. Although much less dramatic, I too recall in this personal blog post the moment my own father is told he should be ashamed for raising a daughter like me.  The dynamic between Salma and her father is also spot on, from the initial pleading and tense compromises to outright threats. Many abusers do indeed imprison their victims to isolate them and prevent them from having any contact with the outside world.

The only sticking point for me was the ending. There is no way that Shahzad would have killed himself after killing his daughter. Men who murder in the name of ‘honour’ are revered and celebrated within the communities from which they spring. Even in jail they are treated like heroes. Deeyah Khan’s Banaz: A Love Story demonstrates how killers will even gloat about what they’ve done as they recall the gory details to an eager audience. Shahzad would have served his time comfortably and re-entered a community that would mostly have welcomed him back with open arms.

But aside from this, I remain struck by the level of detail in this excellent drama, and it is a must-watch especially for those who *still* express incredulity at the possibility that mothers and fathers can manipulate, abuse, beat and even kill their children in this way. You also have to ask yourself how the police would respond to someone like Salma today if she turned up breathless and frantic with fear, telling them that she fears for her life even though her father hasn’t yet laid a finger on her. Would they be in a position to assess the risk competently and support her? A recent report from HMIC is clear that most of them would not.

Shaheen Hashmat

Shaheen Hashmat

Shaheen Hashmat is a Scottish Pakistani writer and campaigner, and the founder of Double Bind. Having escaped the threat of forced marriage 20 years ago when she was 12 years old, Shaheen now spends much of her time highlighting the long-term recovery needs of those affected by forced marriage and ‘honour’-related abuse, focusing specifically on the need for urgent improvement of mental health services. She occasionally writes for Telegraph Wonder Women and the New Statesman, and has also appeared on Radio 4’s Woman’s Hour, BBC Asian Network, Reuters, Stella Magazine and the Scottish Sunday Mail. She is also winner of the Iranian and Kurdish Women's Rights Organisation's 'True Honour' Award 2016. By promoting the voices of other women from a Muslim background, Shaheen hopes to play her part in addressing some of the most urgent issues concerning our generation today. You can follow her on Twitter @tartantantrum, and on her personal blog - www.shaheenhashmat.com.

You may also like...

2 Responses

  1. Ren says:

    It was an utterly gripping film, not a second wasted.
    I’m interested that you thought the suicide of the father unlikely – although I know little about the cultural background of honour killing, that seemed not to ring true to me too. I’d be interested to know why the filmmakers made that decision.
    Thanks for our work and all the best with this new initiative.

  2. Pedro Paulo says:

    Dozens of innocent women were butchered by their own families. drastic measures would be needed such as life sentences with no parole for the perpetrators. ( we should not forget that in saudi arabia people condemned for murder have their head chopped off. ) Besides the families condemned of honour killings should loose their homes which would be turned into shelters for abused women. To change people behaviour sometimes drastic measures are needed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *